Jeurys Familia Presents An Interesting Case Under Baseball’s New Domestic Violence Policy – Forbes
Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred has already decided three cases under Baseball’s new domestic violence policy. However, the next case, involving star New York Mets relief pitcher Jeurys Familia, may present the most challenging factual scenario for the commissioner to date.
On the morning of October 31, 2016, Jeurys Familia was arrested and charged with simple assault in connection with an alleged domestic violence incident in his Fort Lee apartment. A criminal investigation then proceeded.
Six weeks later, a Fort Lee Municipal Court judge dropped all criminal charges against Jeurys Familia, stating that the pitcher’s lack of history of domestic violence and his wife’s insistence that she never felt in danger played a role in the decision.
Nevertheless, pursuant to the Major League Baseball domestic violence policy, Rob Manfred may still choose to discipline Jeurys Familia if the league independently finds “just cause” for doing so.
Although past commissioner suspensions do not serve as binding precedent for future commissioner suspensions, past punishments indeed serve as reasonable guideposts under the “just cause” standard. Moreover, where the players’ association believes a players’ punishment lacks just cause, the union may seek to appeal the punishment to a neutral arbitrator
Under the current policy, Commissioner Manfred has issued three suspensions for alleged player involved in domestic violence — none of which has been appealed to a neutral arbitrator.
Before the start of last season, Commissioner Manfred reviewed a case in which New York Yankees closer Ardolis Chapman allegedly choked and shoved his wife, as well as fired eight gunshots into his garage wall, even though the police ultimately never pressed charges. Commissioner Manfred suspended Chapman for 30 games.
Thereafter, Manfred issued a 52 game suspension to shortstop Jose Reyes after he was arrested and charged with hitting his wife — another incident in which charges were ultimately dropped. Meanwhile, most recently, Manfred suspended Atlanta Braves player Hector Olivera for 82 games after Olivera was arrested and charged with domestic battery.